[Skip to Content]

Plato's Closet - Commack, NY

 Three friends walking and a caption reading now buying your stuff.

 Are you looking to change your look? Sell us your gently used clothes and accessories and recycle your style.

 Photo of a woman holding a handbag and a caption readling too many handbags? Sell to us.

 Sell us your gently used handbags.

A guy in shorts sitting on a beach and a caption reading ”short on cash? We buy guy's stuff"

 Guys, we need you ! We will pay you cash on the spot for your gently used men's apparel.  

Two young lady's and a caption reading we buy and sell plus sizes

NEED MONEY? SELL US your gently used plus size clothing.

Need a  NEW STYLE? Save money while getting that NEW LOOK.

Click here to find out what we're buying now!!!

The team at Plato’s Closet in Commack, New York knows style is personal! That’s why they’re always scouting unique styles from trendsetters like you… And they’ll pay you cash on the spot for your stuff! Sounds too good to be true? Try ‘em! Bring in the gently used casual clothing, shoes and accessories you’re ready to sell! They buy spring, summer, fall and winter clothes no matter the season…
And no appointments are needed!

And while you’re there, take a look around! Plato’s Closet Commack, New York stocks their store with the trendy clothes you sell. That’s why you’ll find brands and styles that you see at the malls—but for up to 70% less than mall prices. You’ll find deals on gently used american eagle, forever 21, BDG, Nike, H & M
and many, many more...

Love to change your style? Our inventory changes every day!
So stop in today and stop in often!

We require a legal form of identification every time you bring items in to sell to us. Please make sure you have one of the following with you: 

1) Driver's License

2) Learner's Permit

3) Non-Drivers Identification

4) Passport

5) Military Identification

Our Location

Plato's Closet Commack

6153 Jericho Turnpike
Commack, NY 11725


Facebook icon Instagram

Gold Star Stores

Gold Standard This location has received the Gold Star Seal. They have been recognized for achieving the highest standards in Product, Quality, Operations and Customer Service.

Want to sell your stuff?

What we're buying:

Athletic wear, dresses, shoes, boots and purses are a few of our top-sellers right now.

read more